I have two. The Ritual and Drowning.
The Ritual is pure smut. 61 chapters and every one contains a graphic, demeaning sex scene. I’m convinced the author was an adult film screenwriter and decided to try their hand at writing a novel. There isn’t a single likable character in this book.
Drowning isn’t a great work of literature. I felt that the characters were very two-dimensional. I hated how naive the author made the protagonist. It made me have a lack of sympathy for her. The ending was series finale of Dexter bad.
I agree, my sister and I read The Night Circus when it first came out, and we both loved it. It’s been a long time since I read it, but I remember it being a rather dreamlike, magical experience. I’ve been wanting to return to it, so perhaps I will, and see if my opinion changes any.
Since we enjoyed Night Circus so much, of course we also read Starless Sea, and that one was…I’m not going to lie, the author really lost me with that book. It felt like an acid trip fever dream. There was way too much wacky stuff going on, and it left me pretty confused. A shame, because it did contain some interesting ideas.