Anyone who isn’t putting Herb in S is not a serious person
I mean I wouldn’t put him in S but like what do you mean? And what do people base these ratings on? Cause I would think how much you like the character, not how much you like them as people
Idk either, it seems like the sub hates on BJ cause he is trash, then everyone has him S or A? So do we really hate him? I love him, id put him in S. And i would put the news whale up there too!!!
Honestly the newswhale, Lenny turtletaub and the guy voiced by either key or peele( always mix them up) shouldn’t be that low. For the low amount of episodes they’re on they’re all integral characters. I think jk simmons was on like under 15 episodes throughout the series despite having multiple parts and the others were on less but I really couldn’t imagine the show without any of them
Todd needs his own tier.
“Hooray! A tier!”
what the fuck is the criteria we are ranking the characters by?? these tier lists are meaningless unless this is specified
honestly didn’t think it through too deeply. ranked them by how i like them as (fictional) people
Why is Ruthie S? She is just a baby. I gotta say that my S would probably be Bojack, Mr peanutbutter, Diane and Dr Hu. So we are not on the same page OP
ruthie is cute and represents a lot of good things for PC, cant not love her
I am extremely neutral towards her. I am happy for PC, but Ruthie as a character is just a baby character. The only character trait that she has that we are aware of is that she laughs at PCs tongue twisters, so I guess I could accept that bumping her up to the B tier. But being in A tier for just being a baby is crazy to me compared to all the amazing lines and amazing character dynamics that we get from Mr peanutbutter
😂 it’s not a super serious tier list. i love cute babies and a happy PC, what can i say
Aah ok. Well I gotta say I got inspired to make my own tier list with my best friend, and we gona take it super seriously and end up screaming at eachother over stupid opinions, so thank you for giving me this idea!
love that! you’ve also maybe inspired me to make a serious ™️ tier list too. get into the nitty gritty of the real contributions and moral character of each person 🤔 post yours when you’re done! love seeing everyone’s opinion on each character
Ruthie is awesome
Why though?
She’s cute and has spikes. And appreciates Ang Lee.
Still S tier for just that is a bit much imo
if we going by just character than Bojack and Mr Peanutbutter are easy S’s imo
At least Tom Jumbo-Grumbo is hilarious. The paparazzis are just annoying
Where’s Corduroy Jackson-Jackson
For y’all being shitty in the comments–there’s no criteria for this tier list. These are OP’s favorite characters and they want to share it with others. I myself respect anyone with Guy, Judah, and character actress Margo Martindale in S tier, bravo
Of course Diane is #1
Wow! An actually good tier list. The only thing I would change is move turtletaub and fuzzyface up.