New Mexico

The one about the anthropomorphic horse who’s the washed up star of an 80s sitcom. What’s all that about?

all of the episodes of them under PBs house with jessica biel and zach braff even though i love zach braff

princess carolyn and rutabaga… i feel like it was just unnecessary tbh

While I can’t really disagree with your points about Vincent, I will say that

“God, can you imagine that body in a swimsuit?”

“I literally cannot”

Is probably my single favorite line in the whole series

I know it’s important to the show, but I ALWAYS skip the New Mexico episode when rewatching. I also hate Henry Fondle

Not a whole episode but the scene where Stuart and and Tracy just genuinely refuse to use the little bit of brain they have to realize they’re siblings lol I get the joke and gesture and all but it just makes me irrationally mad it’s so unsatisfying

Season 5, specifically everything with mr peanutbutter and pickles etc. it felt forced like they just needed an excuse to keep him in the show.

I find Todd’s shenanigans unnecessary to any story

i hated Vince as well, you’re not alone

Everything involving Judah. Just a thoroughly uninteresting character who doesn’t really serve the story much at all. It would be trivial to write around every Judah contribution in the first five seasons (I disregard the sixth when evaluating how essential characters are, because so many characters were wrapped up then because they existed and the show was ending) and not having Judah would make the scenes more interesting.

I loved Vincent adultman. The concept of PC turning around to get a man to make bojack jealous and but the man was 3 kids stacked on top of a trench coat was hilarious.

Pickles

It only went on for an episode, but I didn’t care for hunting down Todd’s kidney.

Vincent Adultman takes the #1 spot, by far.

Runner up- the reporters in season 6