I don’t think there’s anything wrong with rating a book on a personal rating though. At the end of the day isn’t that what determines a book’s worth? If people like it.

Lotr, great movie.

I couldn’t stand the book. Credits to him for creating a whole world of fantasy and language etc, tons of poetry and characters. I’d rate it highly “objective quality” wise.

But I found it a terrible read. I had to flip through multiple parts to finish it.