I know this is probably a common topic. For me, I’m not sure if it’s a “trope” or just totally misinformed writing, but it’s how many authors approach alcoholism. Some examples are Girl on the Train and The House Across the Lake, among HUNDREDS. If anyone else here has struggled with alcoholism, you know it’s not just "i woke up after downing an entire bottle of whiskey but was able to shower, down a cup of coffee, and solve a murder. "

  • Pompi_Palawori@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    The universe bad trope.

    MC is an Orphan? BULLIED. MC sits in class? STUDENTS PUNCH HIM AND REMINDS HIM HE’S A POOR ORPHAN. Mc fights back? TEACHER PUNCHES HIM AND TELLS HIM HE’S AN UGLY POOR ORPHAN. Mc makes a friend? FRIEND BULLIED, FRIEND PUNCHED FRIEND DIES. Mc goes home to orphanage? GETS PUNCHED BY FOSTER PARENTS. Mc pets a cat? CAT MURDERED, CAT PUNCHED BY BULLIES. Mc complains? GET PUNCHED GET STABBED.

    You can give your character a sad backstory without every single character being unrealistically cruel and mean all the time.

    • thepoppyghost@alien.topB
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      1 year ago

      I don’t disagree, but I think authors do this because it is otherwise extremely difficult to capture the experience of being targeted.

      What I mean is, if a character is being specifically targeted for abuse by multiple people over the course of years—an experience not uncommon among children who are “different” in some way—it’s hard to write that sense of frequent harassment, because this type of cruelty might happen a couple times a week but maybe you don’t want to just infodump “highlights” from the last few months, so instead it comes out like this. And to the character it might feel as if everyone is unrealistically cruel all the time, because even though the cruelty isn’t literally constant, it still greatly outpaces kindness. It’s really hard to get the reader to have empathy for that kind of experience if they haven’t personally experienced it, because any examples you give will feel to that reader like merely an isolated incident, but aren’t.

      Does that make sense? I don’t know if I’m explaining this properly.

      It’s still not really a good solution.