I disagree that fatigue only happens when something becomes bad. It also happens when it becomes repetitive. The animation, voice acting, violence and dialogue could all be top notch, but if certain things start happening over and over again like fake out deaths or multiverse events that people have seen a million times before, then plenty of people will check out early.

The Boys might not have lost its audience yet, but if it keeps the same story going over and over again then it most certainly will lose a chunk of it. Like I said, everything surrounding the story is top notch in that show - especially the acting - but it can’t go on that way forever. TWD comics were fairly popular, so the show followed them heavily right up until the end and it lost an insane portion of its audience because it just kept doing the same thing.

I don’t know about this season though, I agree with you on that. Hopefully things pick up.

He didn’t with TWD but that was a cash cow and probably had AMC’s influence all over it.

My only hope is that the show comes to concise and earned end that doesn’t feel rushed or played out.

Not crazily impressed with the animation myself but I’d never describe it as gutter tier. You can tell they put a lot of heart into a lot of the concepts they wanted to recreate. It’ll never look as good as the comics, but the fact they can get close enough that it doesn’t really bother the general public is good enough.