I think that Diane is in the wrong - but it’s not because she shouldn’t have spoken up, or not gotten upset, or anything like that.

It’s because Mr. Peanutbutter was her partner. And Diane got wrapped up in something that would have affected Mr. Peanutbutter without talking to him about it, and even after promising not to do something like she did. They should have been a team.

If they had discussed it together first, maybe they could have found a compromise that would work for both of them. Maybe PB could even have supported her in her actions. Instead, they were publicly cast as oppositional forces.

The lack of teamwork in their relationship is a big part of why they broke up.

“Closure is a made up thing by Steven Spielberg to sell movie tickets. It, like true love and the Munich Olympics, doesn’t exist in the real world. The only thing to do now is just to keep living forward.”

No. Bojack won’t get closure here, and that’s one of the major thesis statements of the show. Bojack doesn’t get closure with Herb, or Penny, or Sarah Lynn, or his mother, or a dozen other characters, he doesn’t get closure with Hollyhock.

And unless extreme circumstances bring them back together, I don’t see any reason for Hollyhock to change her mind.