• 0 Posts
  • 5 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: November 1st, 2023

help-circle

  • I was going to say Edward as well. Both the first time I read it as a kid and on my recent reread I disliked him. He left her in the second book, and just when she starts to be happy with Jacob she breaks his heart to go save Edward’s life. Then Edward is super controlling throughout the third book and causes her relationship with her dad to crumble when her dad is just trying to protect her from the guy that literally made her want to die when he left. Edward sucks.




  • 1 - Absolutely hated it and will never reread, maybe DNF

    2 - Didn’t hate it but still bad, might reread if in a series I otherwise like

    3 - It was okay for it’s genre/audience, not great but not bad either

    4 - It was better than okay, I really liked it, or I loved it but can’t recommend it to everyone due to content

    5 - I really enjoyed/loved it and can recommend it to everyone