• 0 Posts
  • 12 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: October 29th, 2023

help-circle


  • Dirk Gently’s Holistic Detective Agency by the late great Douglas Adams who is more commonly known for his Hitchhikers Guide t the Galaxy series.

    Though to be truthful, I’ve never read it. I have always listened to it on audio read by the author. My first encounter with it was an abridged version which was still quite decent, whoever abridged it did a good job. After the second Dirk Gently book came out unabridged, I had a nice letter exchange with his assistant asking about when the first book would get released unabridged on audio. Long story short, when the contract for the abridged version ran out.





  • Just some more info, the TV show’s first season follows the book pretty closely. The one change I noticed, switching which of two characters dies something, actually makes more sense in the TV show.

    However, the book series goes off in a weird direction while the show does its own thing from season 2 on. I gave up on book two halfway through, but loved the tv series until it jumped the shark. BTW the show shows exactly how the bodies are drained of blood.


  • I was just in another thread yesterday talking about books that were ruined because we had to read them in high school. Except, junior year we read A Fairwell to Arms in America Lit (1984-85 school year) and the entire class was so into it. Afterwards we watched the movie, not sure if it was the 1932 or 1957 version, and we all hated how much they screwed it up. The class got a bit out of control talking about how much and how badly they changed the whole point. I think Mr. Schemer was a bit taken aback at how much these 16-17 year old kids got into that book.



  • I think it’s something that has to be judged in each individual case.

    Sanderson completing Jordon’s Wheel of Time series was planned by Jordon before his passing and appeared to be judged well by the fans.

    Christopher Tolkien going through his father’s notes and publishing more Middle Earth writings were also well received.

    The Salmon of Doubt was published unfinished by Douglas Adams estate after his passing along with some other writings and I liked that. However fans haven’t been as welcoming towards Eoin Colfer’s continuation of the Hitchhiker’s series with And Another Thing.

    I personally hated Go Fetch a Watchmen, a book Harper Lee did not want published, but was released anyway after her death.